How to Dispute a Retaliatory Review from an Airbnb Guest: A Step-by-Step Guide

Negative reviews can be frustrating—especially when they’re completely unfair. I recently had to dispute a 1-star retaliatory review after declining a guest’s refund request for unsubstantiated complaints. To make matters worse, they left behind costly property damage. If you’ve ever found yourself in a similar situation, you know how disheartening it can be.

While disputing a bad review on Airbnb can feel tedious, having a structured approach significantly increases your chances of success. This guide walks you through the exact steps to dispute a retaliatory review, escalate your case effectively, and build a rock-solid defense. Don’t let one bad guest undo your hard work—here’s how to take control and set things right.

1. Careful Screening: Prevention is Better Than Cure

The best way to avoid bad reviews is to prevent difficult situations in the first place. Carefully screen your guests before accepting any booking, especially last-minute reservations. Don’t skip essential screening questions or steps, no matter how rushed the situation may seem. Even with experience and caution, some bad guests may slip through—don’t blame yourself if this happens. Instead, view it as a learning opportunity to refine your process.

2. Document Everything: Protect Yourself with Evidence

Thorough documentation is your best defense if a guest leaves a false or exaggerated review. Before each check-in, ask your cleaners or property inspector to take photos and videos of the space, covering both indoor and outdoor areas. Focus on details that guests are most likely to complain about—such as sinks, toilets, inside the fridge, and oven. Also, document the condition of the neighborhood to counter claims that the area is unsafe. Having a solid record will give you the upper hand if you need to dispute a review.

3. Spot and Report Rule Violations Early

If you suspect that a guest is violating house rules, check your security camera footage and report any infractions to Airbnb immediately. Major violations—such as smoking, hosting unregistered guests, third-party bookings—can often justify immediate cancellation without refund, preventing further escalation. The sooner you document and report these violations, the stronger your position will be if the situation worsens.

4. Require Evidence for Complaints or Refund Requests
If a guest lodges a complaint or requests a refund without clear justification, don’t rush to accommodate them. Instead, ask for specific evidence and document everything on your end. Contact Airbnb to open a case and provide as much supporting material as possible—photos, videos, and written communication. Stay professional but firm, and never issue a refund before conducting a full checkout inspection. Premature refunds can leave you vulnerable if damage or policy violations are discovered later.

5. Set Clear Expectations Before Issuing Refunds
If a refund is warranted, communicate a clear timeline—letting the guest know it may take up to 14 days to process. This allows time for a proper inspection and helps manage expectations. Issuing refunds too quickly may seem like a way to smooth things over, but it can encourage additional complaints and even lead to negative reviews. Taking a measured approach protects your business and ensures fairness for both parties.

6. Disputing a Bad Review: Know the Platform’s Policy

If you receive a retaliatory or unjust review, assess whether it meets Airbnb’s criteria for removal. Airbnb generally allows guests to share their honest opinions (based on what’s true to them), so disputing a review is not always easy. To have a review removed, it must meet one of the following conditions:

• Violates Airbnb’s content policy (e.g., discriminatory, offensive, or irrelevant content).

• False information or misleading claims that can be proven inaccurate.

• Retaliatory intent or a violation of review guidelines.

If you believe the review meets one of these criteria, start the dispute process by submitting a request online. Don’t be discouraged if it gets automatically declined—this is common and often happens initially.

7. Escalate to a Supervisor

If your initial request is denied, call Airbnb and ask to escalate the case to a supervisor. Clearly explain your reasons and provide all the evidence you’ve gathered. Reiterate why the review is unjust and how it could mislead future guests. Be prepared to explain your case multiple times to different customer support representatives if necessary.

8. Be Persistent: Don’t Take ‘No’ for an Answer

If the supervisor still declines your request, don’t give up. Even if they say it’s the final decision, there are often other teams or departments that can review your case. Stay calm, professional, and firm. Highlight how the review unfairly impacts your business and host standing. Try calling Airbnb at different times of the day or on different days of the week—you may encounter someone who is more receptive to your case.

9. Act Like a Defense Lawyer: Build a Strong Case

When requesting a re-evaluation, create a document that breaks down the review point by point, highlighting any inaccuracies or misleading statements. Research the guest’s public information and review history to see if other hosts have faced similar issues. If possible, connect with previous hosts to gather additional insights. Presenting a detailed, factual rebuttal can significantly strengthen your case.

10. Leave an Honest Review to Warn Other Hosts

Whether or not you can successfully dispute a damaging review from a guest, it is important that you leave a factual, professional review of the guest. Be honest about any issues while maintaining a neutral tone. Your review can help warn other hosts and contribute to a stronger, more supportive host community. Remember the guest cannot see your rating, but only what you wrote in your review on them. Lower ratings can result in guests not being able to instant-book with hosts and alerting other hosts to be careful in considering their booking request. Transparency is key to protecting others from difficult guests and fostering trust within the platform.

Final Thoughts: Persistence Pays Off

Disputing a retaliatory review is rarely quick or easy, but with patience, thorough documentation, and persistence, you can protect your reputation and business. Stay professional, stick to the facts, and don’t hesitate to escalate when necessary. Your diligence doesn’t just benefit you—it helps uphold fairness for the entire host community.

Need expert guidance on handling tricky guest situations or optimizing your STR business? Let’s strategize together! 🚀 Book a free 30-minute discovery call today. 📞✨